GDC Logo

Why will we play Darkish Souls?

Posted on

I bear in mind one time my spouse noticed me taking part in Darkish Souls, and I used to be wanting very struggling, so she requested me, “Why do you play such a struggling sport for therefore lengthy?” At that second, I do not know how one can reply the query, as a substitute it additionally led me to a collection of questions, why would anybody make such a tough sport? Why is that this anti-trend design authorized? And why can it turn into a product with tens of tens of millions of gross sales ultimately? As a designer, I believe I have to determine this out.

This evaluation is attempting to clarify why gamers desire to play this “extraordinarily troublesome” title by breaking down how the Darkish Souls franchise meet the psychological want of gamers (Competence) primarily based on the PENS motivational mannequin.


Competence could be outlined because the intrinsic have to really feel a way of mastery or effectance in what one is doing. Quite a few research by Immersyve’s crew have proven that in each work and leisure actions persons are intrinsically motivated to hunt out alternatives to expertise competence and the satisfaction that accompanies it. [Scott Rigby & Richard Ryan, 2007]

Offering Competence expertise in sport requires working arduous in gameplay problem stability, gameplay readability in addition to suggestions.

Gameplay Problem Stability

When gameplay offers challenges that match the participant’s skills, gamers can really feel a powerful sense of satisfaction and a reliable expertise.

As everyone knows, guaranteeing the stability of problem problem and participant means is the standpoint within the optimistic psychology principle “Circulate” by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, which has been broadly utilized in sport design.

The circulate state represents a optimistic psychological state through which an individual performing some exercise is totally immersed in a sense of energized focus, full involvement, and pleasure within the means of the exercise. Stepping into this state requires sustaining the participant within the circulate zone (see Determine 1), and sustaining the circulate zone requires balancing the issue of the problem with the participant’s means to beat it.

Challenges better than means can result in anxiousness, challenges lower than means could make gamers bored, and these unfavourable feelings could make gamers cease the exercise.

The Flow Zone.png
(Determine 1) Circulate zone components

The Darkish Souls collection, at first look, is totally towards this principle. Even at first, the primary Boss will ruthlessly beat the shit out of these harmless novices, stomp them, and plus these insidious traps or “Conspiracies” within the dungeons, inflicting individuals plenty of ache and fall into anxiousness, to not point out the shivering bosses within the later stage, “Despair forward!”, that is the message gamers often present in entrance of bosses’ gates left by different gamers.

Taking part in it’s so annoyed, then how can Darkish Souls let gamers enter the circulate?

Darkish Souls have several types of gamers, they usually have totally different circulate zones.

In keeping with the participant’s sport expertise and abilities, gamers are divided into a number of classes. There are totally different circulate zones for every of the corresponding classes (Determine 2). Hardcore gamers’ challenge-ability ratio of the circulate zone is way better than that of novice customers, so the conventional or low troublesome problem will make these customers bored.

(Determine 2) Several types of gamers have totally different circulate zones

So, does that imply Darkish Souls solely to entertains hardcore gamers?​

Given the gross sales of greater than 28 million copies of the entire franchise, it may be speculated that its goal consumer sorts are broader than solely hardcore gamers, however how does Darkish Souls let several types of gamers enter the circulate in the identical sport?

Jenova Chen’s article “Circulate in Video games” prompt strategies in the case of making video games that may fulfill the circulate expertise of multi-user sorts:

• Combine and match the elements of Circulate;

• Hold the consumer’s expertise throughout the consumer’s Circulate Zone;

• Supply adaptive selections, permitting totally different customers to benefit from the Circulate in their very own approach;

• Embed selections contained in the core actions to make sure the circulate isn’t interrupted.

Right here we concentrate on the final two factors. These two factors recommend that builders want to offer a number of problem choices embedded within the core gameplay to increase the accessible circulate zone. The sport problem needs to be actively chosen by the participant’s core conduct within the sport, somewhat than passively tailored by a DDA (Dynamic Issue Adjustment) system.

In Darkish Souls, though the problem is extraordinarily excessive on the floor, it offers a wide range of fight options to adapt to gamers of various skills, which expands the sport’s circulate zone, and consequently broaden the consumer group. (Determine 3)

Furthermore, the broad circulate zone permits novice to turn into hardcore customers after lengthy hours play, which suggests gamers haven’t got to remain within the circulate zone statically, they’ll bounce to a different circulate zone by utilizing totally different fight answer in sport and expertise totally different kind of circulate, this may increasingly additionally clarify even after gamers have completed the sport, they nonetheless begin New Recreation time and again.

(Determine 3) Darkish Souls adapt gamers’ Circulate expertise by way of the alternatives they construct into the core gameplay, and with what gamers can bounce to different circulate zone.

Let’s take the boss battle in Darkish Souls as a element instance:

We typically divided participant’s fight choices into 3 ranges of problem

Excessive problem choices:

  • Struggle with bare character;
  • Solely use protect parry and riposte (important assault);
  • Use dance mats or bananas because the enter machine, or different fancy challenges;

Regular problem choices:

  • Progress the character, equip robust armors and weapons;
  • Hone your talent: Research boss assault sample, predict boss transfer by studying begin pose of assaults, enhance hand-eye coordination and response velocity;

Low problem choices:

  • Study abilities and tips from on-line information;
  • Summon NPCs or different gamers for assist (1-3 NPCs could be summoned in Darkish Souls 3);
  • Use terrain “BUG” (Capra Demon, Iron Golem and Taurus Demon in Darkish Souls 1), BOSS assault vary “BUG” (the standing Darkeater Midir in Darkish Souls 3 DLC, The Mattress of Chaos in Darkish Souls 1), and so on.;

Such a wealthy choice of fight strategies has tremendously broadened the precise problem vary in order that extra kinds of gamers can discover their circulate zone, all they should do is to maintain attempting and overcome “Phantasm of despair”, and can finally acquire an incredible sense of feat and satisfaction.

Gameplay Readability

Readability is the premise for offering significant suggestions and a assure of equity in fight. It’s much more important for Darkish Souls such excessive depth and low error tolerance franchise. FROMSOFTWARE effectively balanced the artwork expression (VFX, SFX, Digital camera impact, and so on.) on gameplay and creative aspect.

Digital camera: In most battles, there’s little change of digital camera parameters, solely transient and small modifications similar to digital camera shake, zoom in/out, and blur are added to assist convey the load and inertia of strikes.

Colour and Lighting: The characters are clearly separated from the scene, and the “self-illumination” permits characters to be noticed in the dead of night. (Though it’s unrealistic, ^_^)

(Determine 4) Character “self-illumination” in Darkish Souls 3

VFX: It’s easy on the entire. Every VFX’s depth (measurement, shade, and worth) is effectively distributed in response to its gameplay precedence, it by no means fights participant focus with different extra necessary channels like animation, which makes the fight course of fairly clear.

Animation: NPC and character transfer phases embrace: opening pose->anticipation (“antic”)->attack->recovery->finish pose, and the length of every stage is about moderately, as Eric Jacobus mentioned in his weblog What Demon’s Souls can train stunt performers about human motion, “If carried out too shortly, the actions would lack clear arcs and silhouettes. Carried out too slowly, they may lose their weight and inertia.”

sound results: Precisely talk the fight information to assist gamers make the suitable choice, moreover that, they exaggerated sound for high-risk and high-return actions similar to parry->riposte to reward participant.

UI: Strictly abide by the secondary place of offering fight data, very restrained on UI measurement, shade, worth, animation in addition to immediate frequency to offer approach to extra necessary channels.

(Determine 5) Minimalist fight UI in Darkish Souls 3

In case you are curious about gameplay readability, you may test the GDC discuss “Inventive Ideas of VFX”​.

Significant Suggestions: “Die effectively”

Let’s first break down what is going to gamers do within the fight loop:

  1. Remark: The participant clearly observes the method of battle from the start to character loss of life. What number of hits did he obtain? Which monster made the hit? What number of injury factors was it dealt? How lengthy did it make the participant stagger? And so on.
  2. Evaluation: What trigger these hits? Due to his greed with extra hits to the enemy? As a result of it is too early/late to roll? Ingesting Estus Flask at an inappropriate time? Underestimating enemy injury? Unfamiliar with the terrain and rolling right into a nook? And so on.
  3. Enchancment: be taught to manage his greed; preserve calm and never panic; practice himself to enhance focus and response velocity; be taught enemy conduct, enemy transfer sample, assault cadence, injury vary, be taught degree structure, and so on.
  4. Problem once more.

The low error-tolerance attributable to the high-strength enemy makes the participant care about each hit he receives. Because of the superb fight readability, Darkish Souls permits gamers to obviously observe every part from born to die, after which analyze and enhance. Make each loss of life a means of strengthening the participant, and make each loss of life significant suggestions.

Within the means of difficult the boss time and again, gamers can really feel an apparent sense of self-growth, whether or not it is on psychology, participant talent, or boss research, after which will acquire confidence in successful, generate inner motivation of repetitively problem. On this approach, the problem that appeared unimaginable at first was finally overcome by himself, and the participant accomplished a self-transcendence within the sport and out of doors the sport. This sense of feat provides individuals nice satisfaction, which is why some individuals say that the Bosses of the Darkish Souls franchise are mentors to assist gamers overcome themselves.


This text makes an attempt to clarify why this high-difficulty franchise could make tens of tens of millions of gamers benefit from the “struggling” journey from the motivational perspective of Competence, and I plan analyze Autonomy and Relatedness of this franchise in addition to new Darkish Souls tile Elden Ring sooner or later.

Earlier than I play Darkish Souls, I assumed it was only a sport for a small group of hardcore gamers, however once I entered the Northern Undead Asylum, Lordran, Majula, Lothric Castile, Anor Londo, I step by step immersed myself on this chilly, lonely and darkish world, it feels so totally different but so near my current world, and it’s appears revealing the reality to me like these classical artwork type.


  1. Scott Rigby and Richard Ryan, The Participant Expertise of Want Satisfaction (PENS), Founders, 2007
  2. Jenova Chen, Circulate in Video games, COMMUN ACM, 2007
  3. Keza MacDonald and Jason Killingsworth, You Died: The Darkish Souls Companion, BackPage, 2016
  4. Scott Rigby, The Freedom Fallacy: Understanding “Participant Autonomy” in Recreation Design, GDC, 2017
  5. The Recreation Overanalyser, The Design Philosophy of Hidetaka Miyazaki, 2020
  6. Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, Circulate: the Psychology of Optimum Expertise. Harper Perennial, 1990