GDC Logo

Take a peek inside the extent design technique of Horizon Forbidden West

Posted on

Horizon Forbidden West is a HUGE sequel to the already-enormous Horizon Zero Daybreak. Designing anybody a part of this large open world entails engaged on options that intersect with so many different sport parts.

When constructing main ranges that bridge large elements of the sport’s story, that ask turns into much more difficult. At GDC 2022, Guerrilla Video games senior quest designer Blake Rebouche did a breakdown of the hunt “Loss of life’s Door,” a significant early degree that propels the plot ahead and introduces gamers to a variety of key mechanics.

Loss of life’s Door took literal years to finish, and was continuously impacted by design enhancements in several departments. This is a small style of how Rebouche and his colleagues his managed all of these intersecting design challenges. A few of his options his would possibly assist your crew on their subsequent huge sport.

Bunker Buster

Rebouche started work on Loss of life’s Door after its core narrative hook was locked down by the narrative crew and artistic director. The self-esteem of the extent stayed largely full from begin of labor to complete.

Protagonist Aloy enters an enormous bunker looking for a backup copy of an AI named Gaia. She passes via places of work utilized by Gaia’s creators, recovers the AI, however then is attacked by a brand new set of futuristic villains with new sorts of machine enemies. She flees the bunker, utilizing new underwater stealth mechanics to keep away from seize.

Rebouche’s degree design course of will look acquainted for seasoned palms. First, he and the crew sketch out paper prototypes. Then they block out a skeleton model of the extent to flesh out gameplay concepts. After that, a “first playable” model of the hunt is assembled that is prepared for playtest suggestions. Then it is a lengthy technique of iteration and parallel growth till it is time to ship.

Rebouche’s top-level targets for Loss of life’s Door have been constructed on classes from engaged on the bunkers of Horizon Zero Daybreak. he and his crew his needed to construct story-rich environments, cut back fight in opposition to human enemies (this was rated very negatively within the first sport), and cut back artwork / lighting prices.

Earlier than Rebouche even created the paper prototype, he created a beat sheet impressed by the narrative path given, and spelled out what gameplay parts he needed to create to emphasise the extent’s narrative targets.

Paper prototypes of Death's Door.

When displaying off the greyboxed model of Loss of life’s Door to the GDC crowd, Rebouche defined that on this part, the extent design crew intentionally places vivid colours on pathways and objects required to finish the hunt. For the reason that degree is just not prepared for an artwork move at this stage, calling out key options with vivid colours helps the crew perceive the extent’s circulate.

In parsing that circulate, Rebouche additionally started writing “self-talk” dialogue prompts for Aloy that will be handed again to the narrative crew for iteration. Rebouche referred to as out that this was by no means meant to be narrative dialogue, however as a substitute would organically serve to assist nudge gamers via sure puzzles.

One problem the extent design crew confronted in creating Loss of life’s Door was that the Specters (the brand new machine enemies introduced in by the sport’s villains) wouldn’t be finalized for YEARS in manufacturing. Although they are not fight enemies on this zone, they’re alleged to be stalking and monitoring the participant in the course of the climactic stake.

Rebouche did not sweat this. “I used human enemies from the primary sport with lasers on their faces,” he stated (with a straight face). These goofy-looking goons would spend years stalking this part till the Specters have been designed.

First Playable Issues

Transferring from the skeleton prototype to the “first playable” model, Rebouche introduced up the numerous adjustments made to the extent’s closing encounter. After recovering GAIA from a spider-like laptop machine, Aloy is attacked by an invincible opponent, and overcomes them by tearing the spider’s legs off the wall and sending it collapsing to the bottom.

Playtesting within the first playable degree illustrated an early drawback with this plan. All the first prototypes for attacking the spider locked gamers’ deal with this huge machine, that means they did not work together with the boss.

Rebouche tried shifting the tear factors to the close by partitions to repair this drawback, which form of labored, however over time he would notice gamers did not get any probability to work together with this one-of-a-kind creation that felt true to the world.

Flattening the spider’s limbs required use of the Pullcaster (a brand new device launched within the sport’s first hour that lets gamers grapple to things or pull objects towards them). Utilizing the Pullcaster to resolve puzzles turned a central focus of all of Loss of life’s Door, however additional playtesting illustrated an issue that is doubtless acquainted to open-world designers: Gamers generally forgot how you can use this device, though it had been of their stock for hours.

That is as a result of in an open-world sport, gamers may simply have spent hours not utilizing the device by now. Right here Rebouche shared one in every of his new golden guidelines for degree design: “The Golden Nugget.”

“Nuggets” in Rebouche’s vocabulary now seek advice from little “educating” moments that assist gamers keep in mind how you can use sport mechanics. Rebouche would return to the extent’s begin to add these nuggets for a lot of instruments that got here in throughout growth, together with the Shieldwing Glider.

He credited the “nugget” thought as coming from one in every of his colleagues who joined the crew from Eidos Montreal. Certainly one of these applied puzzles was a “charged spear” system that will later evolve right into a battery puzzle, the place gamers needed to cost up empty batteries and pull objects into place to hold them throughout water to a receptacle.

This puzzle served as a “nugget” for each the pullcaster motion and cost system. However the area it lived in would develop into dramatically reshaped by what occurred subsequent.

The prices of iteration

Rebouche’s electrical energy puzzle lived in a piece of Loss of life’s Door he known as the “underwater labs” part. For a very long time, it was anchored round underwater navigation, and was meant to really feel like “cave diving” on this tech-filled bunker.

It was reduce for 2 causes. First, Rebouche obtained higher-level path that they needed extra Pullcaster and Shieldwing Glider segments (this occurred proper because the COVID-19 pandemic began).

Aloy uses the Shieldwing Glider
The Shieldwing Glider in motion in a later part

Second, the underwater degree setting on this area was so poorly rated by playtesters, that footage of Rebouche’s degree was utilized in an inside doc spelling out how to not do underwater traversal.

Rebouche’s design area was additionally impacted right here by different artwork and design departments finishing belongings or mechanics and having them inserted into the world. Hallways have been stretched and shrunk. Traversal instruments have been added, and playtesters started telling the crew the place they’d no clue what was occurring.

This iteration helped Rebouche remedy the aforementioned issues with the spider room boss. Tech artists and different designers got here in to create distinctive objects on the spider-shaped machine that would transfer across the area.

Rebouche referred to as out that this really reverted the general boss struggle to a state shut its unique prototype, the place gamers ignored the boss in favor of the machine. However due to enhancements to the boss AI and extra dynamic motion within the machine’s shootable elements, it got here collectively in an uncommon style.

This was barely uncommon, Rebouche famous, as a result of most design iteration takes builders away from flawed prototypes and towards enjoyable interactions. However right here, the flawed prototype had the bones of the “proper” encounter…they simply weren’t apparent with out different departments.

The extent’s underwater stealth climax lastly obtained much-needed consideration too, because the Specters’ design was finalized and so they have been added to the extent. Although most underwater traversal for the extent was reduce, Rebouche stored one very helpful trick right here.

The gamers’ oxygen meter for underwater traversal allowed them to remain submerged for a set size of time. By timing the hallways’ size to match that meter’s most degree, gamers have been pressured to floor for air in a room stuffed with Specters. It was an excellent device for making certain the brand new creatures had their time to shine.

By the point Loss of life’s Door was able to ship, it had seen a lot evolution though the story beats it communicated stayed the identical. Trying again on the course of, Rebouche stated he appreciated the truth that the extent ‘s story had been so constant, that the extent ‘s early prototypes had been so readable and consultant, and that his crew his may shift so nicely when bigger design adjustments got here to the sport.

And with so many reduce concepts reappearing elsewhere in Horizon Forbidden West, Rebouche ended his discuss with one closing thought for degree designers: “Good concepts are like boomerangs,” he stated. “Even while you throw them away, they usually come again.”