Revisiting Random Encounters

Accessibility Heuristics and Evaluation Requirements for Mobile Video video games

Posted on

Introduction

Given that inception of the mobile app retailers, the popularity of mobile video video games has grown significantly. With the rising recognition of mobile models, the number of avid gamers with accessibility needs using these models has risen as correctly. This warrants an understanding of basically probably the most up-to-date accessibility evaluation significantly for mobile sport builders to incorporate into their sport manufacturing course of. The worldwide inhabitants in 2021 using smartphone models is 3.8 billion of us, a 6.1% year-over-year progress (Newzoo, 2021). Mobile gaming market revenues in 2021 will account for 52% of the worldwide gaming market at a $90.7 billion valuation (App Annie, 2020). This {{industry}} is projected to proceed rising year-over-year (Knezovic, 2020) and its avid gamers have gotten increasingly more further quite a few. A number of in 5 (20.5%) avid gamers of casual video video video games have a bodily, psychological, or developmental incapacity; this compares to fifteen.1% of the American inhabitants whole who’re disabled, consistent with the most recent U.S. Census data (PopCap Video video games & Chauteau, 2008). Older grownup audiences moreover experience primary bodily and sensory decline over time (Rienzo & Cubillos, 2020). Mobile-only avid gamers between the ages of 37-64 make up 42% of the overall demographic (Globalwebindex, 2020). With this in consideration, the concept of accessibility has in latest occasions develop to be a rising cultural subject contained in the mobile gaming {{industry}}. It has develop to be rather more customary throughout the face of elevated dependence on individual acquisition and centered promoting campaigns for producing future enterprise progress. The accessibility advocacy matter will also be coupled with ideas spherical elevating consciousness spherical quite a few participant needs, growing usability requirements for avid gamers with disabilities, and bettering the readability of digital merchandise for the widespread shopper (Rehman et al., 2021). Accessible content material materials moreover targets to make lodging for quite a few human circumstances and impairments, as an example, blindness and low imaginative and prescient, deafness and listening to loss, restricted movement, speech disabilities, photosensitivity, and cognitive limitations (Ballantyne et al., 2018). Nonetheless, initiatives within the path of implementing a holistic technique for making mobile video video games further accessible are typically dismissed by the argument of its marginal impression on enterprise progress.

Current Evaluation and Accessibility Pointers

There are quite a few formal and informal standardized pointers utilized by builders and researchers worldwide for evaluating and assessing the environment friendly accessibility of their video video games. These pointers, or heuristics, are devices derived from institutions and organizations such as a result of the World In depth Web Consortium (World In depth Web Consortium [W3C], 2018), Nielsen Norman Group (Nielsen, 2020), AbleGamers Charity (AbleGamers Charity, 2018), Recreation Accessibility Pointers (Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012), and the Worldwide Recreation Builders Affiliation (Bierre et al., 2004). They’re moreover adopted by private development firms for broadening their player-base and even governments for writing and passing non-discrimination insurance coverage insurance policies or authorized tips. Although these heuristics are primarily used and utilized to the occasion of video video games on all platforms, they are often utilized to generate comparable and equally environment friendly pointers significantly for mobile video video games.

A lot of the heuristic pointers outlined throughout the evaluation of this paper have developed from a variety of years of iteration and proceed to develop in scope. By the use of higher than twenty years of rapidly evolving utilized sciences, the occasion of study requirements for accessible mobile video video games gathers strong influences from a variety of core industries along with the online, shopper merchandise, and data know-how. A sturdy occasion may be the W3C’s Mobile Accessibility Pointers which are derived from the Web Content material materials Accessibility Pointers (WCAG) 2.2 and which for the time being are of their fifth iteration since 1998 (World In depth Web Consortium [W3C], 2021; World In depth Web Consortium [W3C], 2020). It was through these pointers which established usually led accessibility concepts and necessities of perceptibility, operability,understandability, and robustness in UX design. The principle of perceptibility states that data and individual interface components need to be presentable to clients in strategies they’ll perceive. That is probably one of the crucial misused in mobile gaming considering the small show display space of mobile models. Pointers beneath perceptibility embrace providing low-cost default font measurement for content material materials and interaction controls, minimizing the set of launched data on show display to a positive diploma, and sustaining explicit distinction ratios between legible textual content material and background (World In depth Web Consortium [W3C], 2020). The principle of operability states that interface components and navigation need to be sufficiently operable by the individual. That’s the important aspect to reaching environment friendly participant interactions with the game in hand. Pointers beneath operability state that interactable icons akin to widgets need to be sufficiently huge and have ample distance from each other to ensure safe concentrating on by contact (W3C, 2020). Moreover, widgets need to be merely reached on the show display considering the restricted differ of the thumb and the way in which by which the individual might preserve the machine. The principle of understandability states that data equipped by a mobile software program and its operation of individual interface need to be understandable. Mobile video video games lose their engagement when the participant cannot understand its content material materials or the way in which to administration it. Pointers beneath understandability embrace clearly indicating that interactable parts (akin to widgets) are distinguishable from non-interactable parts, sustaining fixed layouts and iconography, and utilizing native-device meta-data for detection by show display readers (W3C, 2020). The principle of robustness states that the equipment’s content material materials need to be appropriately utilized all through all models the individual makes an try and entry it with. This has direct implications on multi-platform efficiency and testing of mobile video video games. These pointers moreover counsel that builders work with emulator devices akin to Apple’s Accessibility Inspector, which allows them to take a look at the accessibility of widgets all through all machine codecs (Dobosz, 2017). Builders should affirm robustness throughout the sport and on every machine model for which it is meant to be carried out. The admissible implementation of these concepts could also be confirmed by native legal guidelines and authorized tips which exist to allow acceptable ranges of accessibility for software program program.

Governments of the USA, Canada, and the European Union have adopted plenty of the success requirements for accessible software program program beneath laws using the WCAG. Given that establishment of these authorized tips, many private firms have moreover launched initiatives and normal proprietary accessibility pointers throughout the development of mobile utilized sciences. Many firms have printed their pointers in an attempt to drive development forward displaying distinctive accessibility choices. One occasion is IBM’s Accessibility Handbook which includes three particularly crafted checklists for designers, builders, and problem managers working in data know-how. These checklists embrace verifications of focus enablement, coloration and varieties, content material materials development, readability, and worthwhile use of the machine’s voice recognition or show display reader settings (IBM Design Accessibility Handbook, 2017). Checklists like these perform a optimistic and proactive occasion for the way in which sport builders may switch forward with making their very personal checklists for quite a few crafts and teams associated to the game making course of. Curiously, there have moreover been makes an try by know-how builders, like Apple Inc., to increase accessibility and worth of functions using third-party software program program. By scanning functions through this system, it permits hardware-based show display readers to perform on prime of beforehand non-operating functions (Zhang et al., 2021). This evaluation has confirmed important enhancements throughout the effectivity of individual interactions using mobile models and can current the {{industry}} with one different constructive technique to rising devices with comparable issues.

One different occasion of a printed industry-recognized set of accessibility pointers is the Recreation Accessibility Pointers (Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012). These pointers have been a collaborative effort between a variety of studios, researchers, and lecturers to produce a developer nice reference for strategies to maximise accessibility in video video games. The foundations are broken down into six lessons which apply to each of the essential factor incapacity groups: motor, cognitive, imaginative and prescient, listening to, speech, and primary. Each class is break up into three difficulties which replicate the trouble and effectiveness of each accessibility perform: basic, intermediate, and superior. Main choices will likely be utilized to quite a lot of sport mechanics and embrace allowing administration remapping, toggling on or off haptic solutions, and passable sizing of interaction controls. Intermediate choices require further planning or sources and embrace assist for a variety of enter models, adjustability of sport velocity, and full interface customizability. Superior choices require sophisticated variations and embrace full show display reader assist, voice over assist, and along with avid gamers with disabilities as a part of the core testing group of sport choices.

Furthermore, private evaluation facilities have made important progress throughout the mobile Vital video video games type by improve gaming experiences for the middle-aged and older grownup inhabitants (Salvador-Ullauri et al., 2020). Vital video video games are a category of video video video games designed for educational features. Korea’s Superior Institute of Science and Know-how developed a specific Mobile Recreation Design Data supported by a wise document of study requirements using video video games like Homescapes, Brawl Stars, and Fruit Ninja with a varied viewers having seen, auditory, and cognitive impairments (Lee et al., 2021). These design pointers embrace quite a few primary mobile sport enhancements throughout the areas of interface, sport tips, and price strategies. As an example, throughout the area of business and price, reward objects that are equipped for commercials is method preferable to interrupting interstitial commercials. Equally, allowing commercials to be merely closed or canceled reduces frustration with the choice of viewing an business which the participant simply is not notably contemplating viewing totally. As well as they embrace sections on rising usability for avid gamers with audio-visual and motor impairments. As an example, providing compatibility with supportive instruments akin to contact pens or controllers. The technique in establishing the foundations used a direct technique with a guide sample group of the older grownup inhabitants, a survey questionnaire, and speak-out-loud in-person playtesting. This method is a sturdy occasion of how builders may advance their very personal design pointers with a user-centric technique.

Lastly, with the wide-spanning consideration spherical accessibility throughout the private and public sectors, a variety of non-profit organizations and foundations have begun working rigorously with the video video games {{industry}} and developed their very personal pointers using a constructive viewers of devoted avid gamers with disabilities. The AbleGamers Foundation has created a set of entry and downside design patterns taught beneath their Accessible Participant Experience Design Certification (APX). The 12 entry design patterns are pointers to reach larger understanding of content material materials by as many avid gamers as attainable, along with these with disabilities. A variety of of the entry design patterns akin to improved precision, clear textual content material, and clear channels are moreover associated for mobile sport accessibility. Improved precision, as an example, explains that exact avid gamers with disabilities might have to manage the precision of actions so that they’ll effectively purpose, switch, or navigate throughout the sport or its interfaces (AbleGamers Charity, 2018). The 12 downside design patterns are pointers for enabling consumption and use of content material materials by these avid gamers as correctly. A variety of of the issue design patterns akin to serving handy, gradual it down, and teaching flooring may be extraordinarily related to bettering mobile sport accessibility. Teaching flooring, as an example, is a perform that allows avid gamers to look at in numerous strategies at their very personal tempo so that they’ll purchase the skills needed to attain the game (AbleGamers Charity, 2018). These entry and downside design patterns are rapidly being utilized by a variety of huge AAA and mobile gaming firms to implement accessible choices for avid gamers. The AbleGamers Charity moreover gives a service for builders to examine their video video games and acquire solutions or solutions from avid gamers with disabilities. This may in all probability be an rather more sturdy different for mobile sport builders to reinforce accessibility of their video video games by testing them immediately with disabled avid gamers. A consolidated document of mobile accessibility pointers significantly chosen from each of the aforementioned sources may be found underneath.

Mobile Recreation Accessibility Pointers

ID

Class

Guideline

Reference

GL1

Perceptibility

Textual content material might want to have a default font measurement of a minimum of 18px or 14px daring.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL2

Perceptibility

“Textual content material will likely be resized with out assistive know-how as a lot as 200%.”

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL3

Perceptibility

“Line spacing is a minimum of space-and-a-half inside paragraphs and paragraph spacing a minimum of 1.5 events larger than line spacing.”

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL4

Perceptibility

Content material materials photos not used as decoration might solely symbolize data of textual content material on that show display.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL5

Perceptibility

Content material materials need to be launched with out the utilization of scrolling in each horizontal or vertical directions.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL6

Operability

Time-limits may be disabled by the individual sooner than encountering them.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL7

Operability

Carry out that makes use of dragging movement for operation will likely be achieved by tappingwithout dragging, besides it is essential.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL8

Operability

Interactable parts are inside thumb differ from bottom corners of the show display in portrait device-orientation and bottom corners of the show display in panorama device-orientation, if related.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL9

Understandability

Components which have the equivalent efficiency are acknowledged persistently.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL10

Understandability

Controls are seen on show display and accessible by the use of a menu risk on show display.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL11

Understandability

Fixed help is given/equipped all by way of the introduction of newest controls and/or efficiency

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL12

Robustness

On machine meta-data is built-in for use of native show display reader setting and voice over setting.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL13

Robustness

Conformance or partial-conformance to native authorized tips and WCAG pointers are to be clearly illustrated on show display.

(World In depth Web Consortium, 2018)

GL14

Entry Design

Improved precision: Avid gamers are ready to manage the precision of their actions so that they’ll effectively purpose, switch or navigate.

(AbleGamers Charity, 2018)

GL15

Entry Design

Distinguish this from that: Avid gamers are ready to manage the presentation of information in a way that allows them to differentiate important parts of information throughout the sport and/or its interfaces.

(AbleGamers Charity, 2018)

GL16

Entry Design

Clear Channels: Avid gamers can select/deselect additional channels (sound, haptic, or VFX) of information so that they’ll reliably take throughout the data.

(AbleGamers Charity, 2018)

GL17

Drawback Design

Gradual it down: Avid gamers can cut back the speed, amount, and variety of events throughout the sport so that they’ll effectively progress.

(AbleGamers Charity, 2018)

GL18

Drawback Design

Teaching flooring: Avid gamers can observe in numerous strategies with out consequence to improvement at their very personal tempo so that they’ll purchase the skills needed to succeed.

(AbleGamers Charity, 2018)

GL19

Drawback Design

Entire Recall: Avid gamers can convey up help particulars concerning the sport that has already been confirmed so that they’ll consider and refresh their information about them.

(AbleGamers Charity, 2018)

GL20

Motor

Contact hit areas need to be a minimum of 2.4cm in diameter for tablet, 0.96cm for cellphone codecs.

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL21

Motor

“Make interactive parts that require accuracy (eg. Contact managed menu decisions) stationary”

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL22

Motor

Guarantee that a variety of simultaneous actions (eg. drag or swipe) is not going to be required to progress and may be carried out with one other enter approach.

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL23

Motor

Allow interfaces to be customized and rearranged and resized.

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL24

Cognitive

“Allow the game to be started with out the need to navigate through a variety of ranges of menus.”

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL25

Cognitive

Assure no essential data (significantly instructions) is communicated by textual content material alone.Reinforce essential data with visualcues and/or audio.

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL26

Imaginative and prescient

“Assure show display reader assist for mobile models.”

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL27

Imaginative and prescient

Stay away from placing essential short-term data outdoor the participant’s center-of-focus.

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL28

Listening to

Assure no essential data is conveyed by sounds alone.

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL29

Primary

Current particulars of accessibility choices in-game.

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL30

Primary

“Embody every associated class of impairment (motor, cognitive, and lots of others.) amongst play-testing contributors, in guide numbers based on age/demographic of goal market.”

(Recreation Accessibility Pointers, 2012)

GL31

Listening to

Current voice dubbing when presenting tales or speech bubbles. Level out who’s speaking in dialogues.

(Lee, 2021)

GL32

Cognitive

Current sport tips and solutions all through loading events.

(Lee, 2021)

GL33

Monetization

Make it easy for avid gamers to indicate off adverts by indicating an in depth risk clearly or an option to pay.

(Lee, 2021)

Evaluation Requirements

The W3C’s Mobile Accessibility Pointers, IBM’s Accessibility Handbook, Recreation Accessibility Pointers, Korea’s Mobile Recreation Design Data, and the APX Certification are all transformational and scientifically established pointers which have been utilized by {{industry}} leaders. Nonetheless how environment friendly are they as heuristics throughout the evaluation of accessibility in mobile video video games? There was expansive evaluation evaluating the effectiveness of these heuristics. Necessary peer-review and development has been made spherical accessible video video games for mobile models. Such evaluation has included the exploration and analysis of direct choices related to explicit disabilities akin to seen impairments, listening to impairments, and cognitive impairments (Jaramillo-Alcázar & Luján-Mora, 2017; Jaramillo-Alcázar & Luján-Mora, 2018; Jaramillo-Alcázar et al., 2017). Each of these articles have utilized and utilized accessibility tips that could the game type of Vital video video games on mobile platforms and positioned excessive violations of pointers and accommodating avid gamers with their respective disabilities. The discrepancies for avid gamers with seen impairments included lack of readable default textual content material measurement, lack of customizable textual content material sizing decisions, and decisions to cut back distracting seen outcomes (Jaramillo-Alcázar & Luján-Mora, 2017). The discrepancies for avid gamers with listening to impairments included lack of fixed audio-visual solutions, use of audio-only cues, or no indication of who’s speaking in sport dialogues (Jaramillo-Alcázar & Luján-Mora, 2018). The discrepancies for avid gamers with cognitive impairments included incapability to avoid wasting plenty of settings, not ample hints for finishing up sport aims, and lack of controls customization (Jaramillo-Alcázar et al., 2017). These situations current us that using pointers may assist us moreover in determining factors with our current video video games. Together with this evaluation evaluation, a variety of qualitative analysis, with a conceded effort to legitimize positive industry-leading accessibility pointers, have found most top-grossing mobile functions to be totally inaccessible (Ballantyne et al., 2018). Proper right here, design heuristics have been utilized to ascertain accessibility factors for avid gamers with motor, listening to, cognitive impairments, and folks influenced by the implications of bodily and cognitive decline due to getting outdated. The study merely makes use of the foundations listed from the W3C, experiences with an observational analysis of mobile functions utilized by of us with disabilities, selects the associated accessibility pointers, after which creates a coherent and digestible document for mobile builders to profit from. This method of study will likely be then translated into digestible enhancements that could be built-in into the mobile sport manufacturing course of. Considering the restricted sources sport teams sometimes have, it is vitally essential sequentially prioritize the enhancements consistent with severity and complete estimated effort sooner than assigning new content material materials duties (Rehman et al., 2021). Furthermore, for scientific analysis of the outcomes, it is essential to have the obligatory A/B testing infrastructure with the intention to evaluate whether or not or not enhancements have resolved any violations or how key effectivity indicators have been impacted. This technique is normally a cyclical and iterative course of to creating optimistic change throughout the individual experience for avid gamers with disabilities or impairments. A summary and smart step-by-step technique to evaluation requirements with the cycle for iteration will likely be found underneath.

Evaluation Requirements and Iteration Cycle

Steps

Description

Division

1

Be taught and familiarize your self with the rule of thumb sources.

Enterprise Intelligence

2

Extract associated pointers related to your participant base, type, and sport platform.

Administration

3

Set up areas of violation in your sport’s design and use the accessibility pointers equipped to resolve these violations.

Design

4

Distribute each violation into an merely digestible development initiatives/duties to be prioritized based on severity and place them into the game manufacturing course of.(Rehman et al., 2021)

Manufacturing

5

Develop and implement the choices.

Enchancment

6

Verify and measure with a associated and passable sample group the implementated choices.

Prime quality Assurance/UX Evaluation

7

Create a report and analysis of the measure to understand an understanding of whether or not or not violations have been resolved and the individual experience has benefited key effectivity indicators (KPIs).

Enterprise Intelligence

Conclusion

There have been a very long time of study to variety a variety of acknowledged accessibility necessities for the utilization of software program program, web, data know-how, and video video games. After all this time and effort, ample thorough qualitative and quantitative analysis of industrially standardized accessibility pointers has taken place and spawned an important space of curiosity group of researchers and builders who try for optimistic change in our industries. Plenty of this success is because of progress of rapidly accelerating utilized sciences and passionate researchers spherical accessibility. Within the meantime, it is nonetheless clear that avid gamers with seen, auditory, and motor disabilities may experience further enhancements of their enjoyment of mobile video video games if builders utilized well-researched methods and choices. A considerate technique to the equipment of pointers using mobile Vital video video games can current builders strategies of providing gameplay enhancements for a lot of who need it. Sturdy and user-centric approaches by Korea’s Superior Institute of Science and Know-how current builders the way in which to reinforce validity throughout the software program of accessibility heuristics with a user-centric technique. There are a large number of sources linked to this thesis evaluation to help builders improve their design, implementation, and testing of choices for making further accessible mobile video video games. Furthermore, as the need for further cohesive steering and smart processes throughout the rising mobile gaming {{industry}} will improve, this evaluation offers acceptable examples and a sturdy place to start for that rising need to be fulfilled. Lastly, this evaluation is supposed as a provide of advocacy for all avid gamers to have the pliability to take pleasure in mobile video video games that are carried out and beloved by tons of of 1000’s day by day.

References

AbleGamers Charity. (2018, February 13). Ablegamers accessible participant experience. Accessible.Video video games. https://accessible.video video games/accessible-player-experiences/

App Annie. (2020, December 18). Worldwide Market Share. Retrieved July 29, 2021, from https://www.appannie.com/en/

Ballantyne, M., Jha, A., Jacobsen, A., Hawker, J., & El-Glaly, Y. N. (2018, November 25). Analysis of accessibility pointers of mobile functions [Research article]. Conference on Mobile and Ubiquitous Multimedia, Cairo, Egypt. https://doi.org/10.1145/3282894.3282921

Bierre, Okay., Hinn, M., Martin, T., Mcintosh, M., Snider, T., Stone, Okay., & Westin, T. (2004, June 29). IGDA accessibility in video video games: Motivations and approaches. G3ict. https://g3ict.org/publication/igda-accessibility-in-games-motivations-and-approaches

Dobosz, Okay. (2017). Designing mobile functions for visually impaired of us. In J. Estrada (Ed.), Visually impaired: assistive utilized sciences, challenges and coping strategies (pp. 103–126). Nova Science Publishers, Inc. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/321319458_Designing_Mobile_Applications_For_Visually_Impaired_People

Recreation Accessibility Pointers. (2012). A easy reference for inclusive sport design. http://gameaccessibilityguidelines.com

Globalwebindex. (2020). Gaming personas – an viewers profile on the digital attitudes and behaviors of six gamer varieties[PDF]. globalwebindex.com. https://strivesponsorship.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/GlobalWebIndex-Gaming-Personas-Viewers-Report-2020.pdf

IBM design accessibility handbook [PDF]. (2017). IBM Accessibility Handbook. Retrieved February 26, 2021, from https://accessibility-handbook.mybluemix.net/design/a11y-handbook/

Jaramillo-Alcázar, A., & Luján-Mora, S. (2017). Mobile essential video video games: an accessibility analysis for people with seen impairments. TEEM 2017: Proceedings of the fifth worldwide conference on technological ecosystems for enhancing multiculturality, (66), 1–6. https://doi.org/10.1145/3144826.3145416

Jaramillo-Alcázar, A., & Luján-Mora, S. (2018). An technique to mobile essential video video games accessibility analysis for people with listening to impairments. In Proceedings of the worldwide conference on data know-how & strategies (icits 2018) (pp. 552–562). Springer Worldwide Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-73450-7_52

Jaramillo-Alcázar, A., Luján-Mora, S., & Salvador-Ullauri, L. (2017). Accessibility analysis of mobile essential video video games for people with cognitive impairments. 2017 Worldwide conference on data strategies and laptop computer science. https://doi.org/10.1109/INCISCOS.2017.12

Knezovic, A. (2020, October 9). Mobile gaming statistics: 85+ statistics for 2020 | udonis. Udonis. https://www.weblog.udonis.co/mobile-marketing/mobile-games/mobile-gaming-statistics

Lee, S., Oh, H., Shi, C.-Okay., & Doh, Y. (2021). Mobile sport design data to reinforce gaming experience for the middle-aged and older grownup inhabitants: Shopper-centered design technique. JMIR Vital Video video games, 9(2), e24449. https://doi.org/10.2196/24449

Newzoo. (2021, July 1). Newzoo world video video games market report 2021 | free mannequin | newzoo [PDF]. https://newzoo.com/insights/trend-reports/newzoo-global-games-market-report-2021-free-version/?utm_campaign=GGMR 2021

Nielsen, J. (2020, November 15). 10 usability heuristics for individual interface design. Nielsen Norman Group. https://www.nngroup.com/articles/ten-usability-heuristics/

PopCap Video video games & Chauteau, G. (2008, June 11). Popcap video video games evaluation. GamesIndustry.biz. Retrieved October 10, 2020, from https://www.gamesindustry.biz/articles/popcap-games-research-publisher-s-latest-survey-says-that-casual-games-are-big-with-disabled-people

Rehman, U., Abbasi, A., Shah, M., Idrees, A., Ilahi, H., & Hlavacs, H. (2021). Analyzing and prioritizing usability factors in video video games. In Lecture notes in laptop computer science (pp. 110–118). Springer Worldwide Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-77277-2_9

Rienzo, A., & Cubillos, C. (2020). Playability and participant experience in digital video video games for aged: A scientific literature consider. Sensors, 20(14), 3958. https://doi.org/10.3390/s20143958

Salvador-Ullauri, L., Acosta-Vargas, P., Gonzalez, M., & Luján-Mora, S. (2020). Blended approach for evaluating accessibility in essential video video games. Utilized Sciences, 10(18), 6324. Retrieved December 17, 2020, from https://doi.org/10.3390/app10186324

World In depth Web Consortium. (2018, June 5). Web content material materials accessibility pointers (WCAG) 2.1. Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI). https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG21/

World In depth Web Consortium. (2020). Web content material materials accessibility pointers (WCAG) 2.2. Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI). Retrieved July 27, 2021, from https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG22/

World In depth Web Consortium. (2021, May 14). Mobile accessibility at W3C. Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI). Retrieved July 27, 2021, from https://www.w3.org/WAI/standards-guidelines/mobile/

Zhang, X., de Greef, L., Swearngin, A., White, S., Murray, Okay., Yu, L., Shan, Q., Nichols, J., Wu, J., Fleizach, C., Everitt, A., & Bigham, J. P. (2021, May 8–13). Show recognition: creating accessibility metadata for mobile functions from pixels [Research Article]. 2021 CHI Conference on Human Parts in Computing Strategies, Yokohama, Japan. https://doi.org/10.1145/3411764.3445186